Stems & CartridgesThe faucet valve parts index

Look-alike comparison

Kohler GP500520 vs GP876851: unit alone or cap and unit kit

GP500520 is Kohler's Rite-Temp pressure balancing unit by itself. GP876851 is a kit: the round-stem GP77759 mixer cap plus GP800820, the unit Kohler says replaces GP500520. Both serve the same valves, so the valve does not decide. The stem does: the unit has none.

Jump to: side by side, tell them apart in the hand, FourHome replacements.

Schematic drawing of a Kohler pressure balancing unit with no stem, and a notch and two small O-rings on the back end
Schematic of the Kohler unit as Kohler describes it, not to scale. It shows only the features named on this page. No bench photo of this part yet.

Part record: Kohler GP500520

Schematic drawing of a Kohler mixer cap with a round splined stem, a black cap, a metal collar held by two cap screws, and the pressure balancing unit behind it
Schematic, not to scale. It shows only the features named on this page. No bench photo of this part yet.

Part record: Kohler GP876851

Side by side

On a phone, swipe the table sideways to see every column.

FeatureGP500520GP876851
What the number coversPressure balancing unit only, no capKit: GP77759 cap plus GP800820 unit
StemNone; Kohler puts the stem on the capRound, splined, on the GP77759 cap
Early K-304, brass cap, three-ribbed stemNot enough alone, per Kohler AssistThe combination Kohler Assist requires
Drip at showerhead, valve leak confirmedKohler's guide names the kit, not the unitKohler's guide names the mixer cap and PBU kit
Valves (Kohler 2011 catalog)K-304, K-305 before 2009, K-11748Same valves, through GP77759 cap and the unit
Kohler number statusEarlier number; GP800820 replaces itCurrent kit number in Kohler's brochure; Kohler's K-304 instructions call the cap and PBU kit GP76851
BroachNone, no stem19-point per Everbilt 71869, sold for kit GP76851; no Kohler figure
FourHome boxOne pressure balancing unit, no mixer capCap, unit, four O-rings, two cap screws

Tell them apart in the hand

  1. Check the stem and cap. With the trim off, both parts belong to a round splined stem under a black plastic cap held by two screws. A square stem is a Coralais valve, outside this page; see the GP77886 comparison. Four or six screws mean other Kohler valves.
  2. Brass cap: count stem ribs. A brass cap marks an early K-304, and Kohler's identification tool then asks how many rib segments the stem has. Kohler Assist says a new unit behind a three-ribbed brass cap needs the GP876851 combination, so GP500520 alone is not the order.
  3. Find the stemmed piece. Once the cap is out, the stem stays on the cap. The unit pulled from the brass body behind it has no stem. If the stem, the cap or its springs failed, the unit alone does not replace them; GP876851 carries the cap.
  4. Read the unit's back. Kohler describes a notch cut into the back of the unit that lines up with a tab in the brass body, and small O-rings in oval-shaped seats on the back. Kohler service kit sheet 1250244 has the installer line up the word COLD on the regulator with the cold inlet.
  5. Match the symptom. Kohler's drip guide: water from the showerhead with the valve leak confirmed calls for the mixer cap and PBU kit. Boots and springs that fell out of a pre-2005 cap are not sold; the cap is replaced. Both answers point to GP876851.
  6. Keeping the old cap. Only a sound cap on a black plastic two-screw valve stays. Kohler then has new medium O-rings and a large O-ring fitted to that existing cap before it goes back over the new unit. That is the GP500520 job.

What does not tell them apart

Not printed on this page

Where the sources disagree, the figure is left off until it is settled.

FourHome replacements

The FourHome replacement for each part is on that part's record, linked from each column and below.

FourHome publishes this site. The buttons go to our own listings on Amazon.

Sources

  1. Kohler Common Service Parts Brochure (JOB019705-02)
  2. Kohler Service Parts, Faucets catalog, November 2011, pages 18 and 19
  3. Kohler interactive manual, Identifying Single-Control Shower Valves (1288570-3)
  4. Kohler Assist, Pressure-Balancing Unit (PBU)
  5. Kohler Assist, Rite-Temp K-304 Service Part Installation Instructions
  6. Kohler Assist, Rite-Temp Valve Dripping from Showerhead or Spout
  7. Kohler Service Kit Instructions 1250244-9-B, as hosted by Noel's Plumbing Supply
  8. Kohler Service Parts Guide, Fairfax Rite-Temp trim (1004634-8-B)
  9. Noel's Plumbing Supply, Kohler K-GP76851 Rite-Temp Mixer and Pressure-Balancing Unit
  10. Home Depot, Everbilt 71869, replaces Kohler GP76851
  11. Home Depot, Everbilt 49868, replaces Kohler GP500520 and GP800820
  12. FourHome listing on Amazon

Catalogs disagree now and then, and makers revise parts without changing the number. Compare the old part before buying.