Stems & CartridgesThe faucet valve parts index

Look-alike comparison

Pfister 910-382 vs 910-374: threaded diverter or smooth hot and cold

Pfister 910-382 and 910-374 are brass compression stems from multi-handle tub and shower valves, both with a 12-point broach. 910-382 is the diverter behind the center handle and has outside threads on its bonnet. 910-374 is the hot and cold stem, and its bonnet is smooth.

Jump to: side by side, tell them apart in the hand, FourHome replacements.

Schematic drawing of the Pfister 910-382 diverter stem with a 12-point broach and a bonnet with external threads
Schematic, not to scale. It shows only the features named on this page. The lower end is left blank because sources describe the tip differently. No bench photo of this part yet.

Part record: Pfister 910-382

Schematic drawing of the Pfister 910-374 stem with a 12-point broach and a smooth bonnet with no outside threads
Schematic, not to scale. It shows only the features named on this page. The lower end is left blank because no source gives the tip. No bench photo of this part yet.

Part record: Pfister 910-374

Side by side

On a phone, swipe the table sideways to see every column.

FeaturePfister 910-382Pfister 910-374
Job in the valveDiverter: center handle, sends water to spout or showerheadHot or cold supply: left or right handle
Outside of the bonnetExternal threads (genuine part at Home Depot)Smooth, no threads (Danco 12H-2H/C equivalent)
How it is soldDiverter Stem with External Threads; Diverter Stem & BonnetShower Stem (Pfister spec sheet); Hot and Cold Replacement Stem
BrassCraft replacementST5324, filed as DiverterST5326, filed as Hot/Cold
Cap thread gasket, BrassCraft catalogSC0262SC0198
Broach12-point, code H (BrassCraft)12-point, code H (BrassCraft, Danco)
Stem gauge classLength 12 (BrassCraft)Length 12 (BrassCraft, Danco)
Bibb seatSeparate part; FourHome listing names 970-500 seatsSeparate part; Pfister says order 970-5000

Tell them apart in the hand

  1. Note which handle. Tag each stem with its opening as it comes out. A stem from the center handle is the diverter, so between these two it is 910-382. A stem from the left or right handle is the hot and cold stem, 910-374. BrassCraft files them as Diverter and Hot/Cold.
  2. Feel the bonnet. Run a fingernail around the outside of the bonnet that came out with the stem. Home Depot sells the genuine 910-382 as a diverter stem with external threads. Danco sells its 910-374 equivalent with a bonnet and no threads. Threads point to 910-382, bare metal to 910-374.
  3. Make both answers agree. A center stem with a smooth bonnet is neither: that is the 910-385 diverter, which one parts seller warns looks like 910-374 and does not interchange. A side stem with outside bonnet threads is 910-372, the threaded hot and cold stem.
  4. Skip the spline count. Both have a 12-point broach, catalog code H, and BrassCraft puts both in gauge length 12. Counting splines or setting either on a stem gauge will not separate them. Use them only to rule out a different maker's stem.
  5. Read the number. Look for 910-382 or 910-374 on the old stem or its card. Pfister's parts site now carries 910-374 as model 910-3740, so either form means the hot and cold stem.

What does not tell them apart

Not printed on this page

Where the sources disagree, the figure is left off until it is settled.

FourHome replacements

The FourHome replacement for each stem is on that part's record, linked from each column and below.

FourHome publishes this site. The buttons go to our own listings on Amazon.

Sources

  1. Pfister spec sheet SS-910-374X, shower stem 910-374
  2. Pfister parts page, compression stem model 910-3740
  3. Pfister spec sheet SS-910-385X, diverter stem 910-385
  4. BrassCraft Service Parts catalog SP-0341, Stems/Cartridges by Length, pages B-127 to B-129
  5. Home Depot, Pfister 910-382 Diverter Stem with External Threads
  6. Home Depot, Pfister 910-374 Marquis Hot and Cold Replacement Stem
  7. Home Depot, Pfister 910-372 Hot and Cold Stem with External Threads
  8. HD Supply 413708, Danco 12H-2H/C stem with bonnet, no threads
  9. Home Depot, Danco 12H-2H/C stem (17335B), replaces 910-374
  10. HD Supply 475324, replacement for mfg 910-382
  11. Chicago Faucet Shoppe, Pfister 910-382 Diverter Stem & Bonnet
  12. PlumbingSupply.com, Stems and Cartridges by Price Pfister
  13. PlumbingSupply.com, Price Pfister three-handle tub and shower repair parts
  14. FourHome listing on Amazon

Catalogs disagree now and then, and makers revise parts without changing the number. Compare the old part before buying.